Wait, We're Paying Them?
The New York Times reports that thanks to a complicated tax structure, partners of the Blackstone Group will, over the course of 15 years, receive $1.1 billion in tax deductions for their IPO. That’s $198 million over what the partners will pay in taxes on the stock sale, meaning that they will not only avoid paying taxes on the IPO but will actually earn a negative tax of some $200 million.
Once you get past the shock of this fact, the most vexing part of the whole thing is that Blackstone’s negative tax turns on an accounting fiction known as good will, “the value of the intangible assets, like a well-known brand name, that are built up by a company over time.” The NYT’s David Cay Johnston explains how they’ll do it:
Individuals who create good will cannot deduct it. But when good will is sold the new owners can [deduct it] because its value is assumed to erode. The Blackstone partners sold the good will from their left pocket to their right.
It’s a nice trick I don’t recommend trying on your next 1040: sell yourself some quantity of fading charm or falling beauty and take a deduction for your future losses. But what won’t work for you will work for Blackstone, and with that bit of financial legerdemain the Blackstone partners will actually turn a profit off the U.S. Treasury.
It’s their business if the super-rich want to get richer, but you’d think they could have the courtesy to leave the rest of us out of it. As it stands, for the next 15 years we the people will be subsidizing the depreciation of Blackstone’s good will, an entity whose existence—especially of late—one has very good reasons to doubt.
