
The Lyric Touch: Essays on the Poetry of Excess, John Wikinson’s book of mostly-collected criticism, is now out from Salt. The essays’ main subjects are poets who came of working age during and just after the British Poetry Revival: John James, Denise Riley, Douglas Oliver, J.H. Prynne, and Tom Raworth. A few American poets (John Weiners, Robert Creeley, Mina Loy) attract his attention as well, and the book includes two essays (on Marjorie Welish and Andrea Brady) that made their first appearances in Chicago Review.
(The next issue of CR will include Wilkinson’s response to Peter Riley’s letter about Wilkinson’s review of Simon Jarvis’s Unconditional. For Robert Archambeau’s jaunty summary of that debate, see here and here.)
The question Wilkinson returns to time and again in his criticism has to count as one of the central questions facing any poet working today: can there be lyric poetry that is not somehow Romantic? What both worries and thrills Wilkinson about Romanticism is its excess, an excess capable of both frustrating and inspiring the dream of political justice. But what is poetry without excess? In a sense, this is the same question that American visual artists were grappling with forty years ago, when modernism gave way to minimalism and, in Michael Fried’s terms, art yielded the stage to objects.
(For a clear and convincing demonstration of the political implications of Romantic attitudes about art—also a useful summary of one of the Frankfurt School’s favorite arguments—see Wolf Lepenies’s Tanner Lectures, The End of “German Culture.” [PDF])
Wilkinson’s subjects are not mere props for his own theorizing. As he writes in the introduction, one of the essays’ major objects is to satisfy “an intense need to argue, for myself as well as for others, the value of poets scarcely heard of when I was writing. This is the kind of thing poets should do, and which the academy should better appreciate and promote.”
The Lyric Touch is available from Salt and from Amazon,
as is his recent book of poems, Lake Shore Drive (Amazon
| Salt)