Richard Posner’s Visible Hand
Eliot Spitzer wrote recently about how surprised he was to read that Richard Posner no longer believes that free markets are capable or competent to determine CEO salaries and mutual-fund fees:
Posner concluded that while judges shouldn’t directly review corporate salaries, evidence of unreasonable compensation could be evidence of a breach of fiduciary duty. Yes, these are legal words, but they reveal a remarkable conclusion—courts should take a hard look at private-compensation issues—and demonstrate how far, and rapidly, the world has shifted. The two issues Judge Posner examined—setting CEO compensation at major companies and determining the fees to be paid to mutual fund-management companies on the base of trillions of dollars of mutual-fund investments—are central to the governance of our financial system. It is remarkable that a leader in Chicago School thought would acknowledge that the market is so broken that it can’t be properly trusted on those two critical issues. Yet that is exactly what Judge Posner has concluded.

