Two Views: On Nationalization
1/ Jane Dark:
Over at the suddenly and excellently renascent Ads Without Products, the suddenly and excellently erstwhile CR has been making a vital record of the guilty half-repressed flowering of nationalization talk in the national discourse — patiently noting that while the measures discussed are always simultaneously disavowed, and not really full-nationalization (much less socialism), it remains the case that
…every time they dress the windows with this sort of talk, every time the government players offer the argument that General Motors or Chrysler would have been better managed by responsible, sane, and forward-thinking bureaucrats rather than their board and corporate management, they turn the wheel of discursive normativity a click toward state management and the economics of planning….
…
[W]e fear one could make what is, in effect, a quite contrary claim.

