Fairness? But this is America!
I’ve hit this theme before, but I happily yield the floor to Matt Browner Hamlin, who bops Joe Nocera for a dumb paragraph in his column on executive pay cuts today:
The hypocrisy of how the contracts of Wall Street executives are being treated versus those of union workers is simply stunning. All I want to see in an economic crisis is fairness. If contracts are inviolable, they are inviolable for everyone, regardless of whether they are between blue collar workers in factories, white collar workers in office complexes, or the multi-millionaire executives on Wall Street. If the economic crisis demands that auto workers take a haircut on their pay, benefits, and pensions, Wall Street executives must be held to the same standard. Conversely, if the contracts between big banks and investment firms and their top executives simply cannot be changed, then it’s time to go back and honor the contracts between the auto industry and organized labor.
(To be fair, the sanctity of AIG’s bonus contracts really isn’t Nocera’s subject. He argues that Kenneth Feinberg, the so-called pay czar, can only prescribe cosmetic limits to Wall Street’s compensation mania, which is true. But still.)


That’s pretty bad.